To use a clutch fan or not?

Discussion in 'Engine Topic' started by lapedr, Oct 24, 2017.

  1. Ihada70Z28B4

    Ihada70Z28B4 Veteran Member

    130
    10
    Oct 4, 2002
    Buffalo,NY,USA
    You can find some good ones in the scrapyard. The Ford and Dodge fans work great and not to hard to swap in. Most fans I have used pull about 8-10 amps which is not much. In my Camaro I use a small one from an 80's GM with the 3rd gen aluminum Radiator and it stays between 185-195 on a 90 degree day. I also use a cheap parts store thermo fan controller w/relay. The only thing to make it better would be a way to shut it off after 15 mph where it starts to impede airflow.
     
  2. Burd

    Burd Veteran Member Lifetime Gold Member

    289
    39
    Oct 6, 2011
    Detroit Mi
    My clutch went back in the 80's. I bought a flex fan, had overheating issues, bought a new one at the dealer, glad I did, w/a160 thermo is great now. nOS would be insane now.
     
  3. twozs

    twozs Veteran Member

    8,421
    78
    Aug 5, 1999
    hopewell jct ny
    In 1973 the Z28 has a fixed 7 blade fan which was one for one drive fan ( without ac ) . At idle the fixed fan only turned as fast as the motor rpm . The fluid coupling fan would actually spin faster than the rpm of the motor at idle . I think the fluid drive fan on the z28 was gone in 72 ?? So who knows what’s better , but ac cars like the fact that the fluid fan moves more air owner the condenser coil at idle ( instead of the head pressure going through the roof ) . Eventually the fluid can leak out , then it’s just a regular fan and eventually becomes a hood destroyer ...
     
  4. BillyDean7173

    BillyDean7173 Veteran Member

    396
    46
    May 21, 2014
    Hutto, TX
    This has been very helpful. My 73Z has AC. It was a basket case and all I have is the original 7-blade fan and spacer. Maybe I need to think about a change as well.
     
  5. Rdobbs1977

    Rdobbs1977 Veteran Member

    263
    8
    Dec 1, 2014
    TN
    Mechanical Fans--that's a NO BRAINER, you'd run the clutch fan. You'd want a fan that can spin at different speeds dependent upon temp vs. a fan that's one set speed. As far as hp, it'd be minimal between the two and not worth the bother of influencing a decision.
     
  6. lapedr

    lapedr Veteran Member Gold Member

    459
    1
    Jan 28, 2003
    Pembroke, GA
    Yes great video, I went ahead and bought a 7 blade repo of the 18" 70Z28 fan and fan clutch
     
  7. budro6968

    budro6968 Veteran Member

    1,221
    124
    Apr 2, 2016
    Jax Florida
    Clutch fans are great until you have one lock up at highway speed and disintegrate. But I still would go with the thermostatic type any day.
     
  8. 200mph

    200mph New Member

    1
    0
    Oct 22, 2008
    NC
    You want a thermostat controlled electric fan.

    1) Get a "puller" fan that mounts behind the radiator. Its a bit more effective than a "pusher".
    2) Look for a fan with curved blades... they run quieter.
    3) For best longevity, stick with name brands like Spal and Hayden.
     
  9. Bopfly

    Bopfly Veteran Member

    221
    7
    Dec 8, 2015
    Griffin, Ga
    Gen 4 dual fan set up with a Gen 3, 94 amp alternator and the controller of your choice. I went with the Delta Current Control FK75. Install was about 30 minutes beginning to end. Easy money and my 406 never goes over 180, even on a hot summer day in South Georgia.
     
  10. AJ81Z28

    AJ81Z28 New Member

    27
    0
    Mar 21, 2017
    I gained HP by dumping the old non flex fan. First I tried a clutch fan with the thermostat which actually worked great. But I went to an electric and the car runs faster and is much less noisy. Both the old fan and the clutch fan are loud.
     

Share This Page